Posted by
on Wednesday, July 30th 2008
This is part of the Real Estate Contract Fundamentals Series. I’m not giving you legal advice - you’ve got to get that for yourself from a qualified attorney. To get a free copy of the Real Estate Purchase and Sale Agreement upon which this series is based, visit the Monster Purchase And Sale Agreement Download Page.
———-
If you’ve ever made an offer to purchase real estate, you’ve probably been asked to make an earnest money deposit.
Officially, earnest money is a payment that’s designed to show “good faith”. There’s no legal standard for it. Usually the buyer pays earnest money, but sometimes the seller will do so. Sometimes it’s a small amount - maybe only $10 - and sometimes it’s thousands of dollars.
Generally, it works like this: The buyer puts up a particular amount of money upon making an offer to purchase a property. That money is held by one of the real estate brokers or attorneys/title companies involved in the transaction. When the transaction closes successfully, the money is given to the seller. If the transaction doesn’t close due to default of the seller, the buyer’s money is returned. If the buyer defaults and thus doesn’t close, the seller keeps the earnest money.
Earnest money is not a requirement to have a valid real estate contract. Many real estate brokers will tell you otherwise, but that’s simply a commonly held misconception. However, earnest money is so widely known and expected that it may not be worth your effort to dissuade a seller from requiring earnest money from you.
The real questions about earnest money are:
- How much should you pay?
- Who holds the earnest money?
- What is the criteria for releasing the money?
- What happens to the earnest money in the event that either buyer or seller breaches the contract?
How much earnest money should you pay? I think the answer should be as close to ZERO as possible. Generally speaking, the payment of earnest money does nothing positive for the buyer and should thus be minimized to as little as $5 or $10 if the seller can be convinced of it. The biggest exception to this rule should be in the event that there are multiple parties competing to acquire the property. In that case, a significant earnest money deposit can sometimes be the factor making a seller decide in your favor.
Who holds the earnest money? If the earnest money in question is a small amount, such as under $100, I don’t think it really matters who holds it. But if it’s a larger amount, then you should be sure to either hold the earnest money yourself, or have it held by your broker, attorney or title company. There’s no good reason to relinquish control of your money to a party who isn’t working on your behalf unless it’s absolutely necessary.
What is the criteria for releasing the earnest money? For example: If the buyer inspects the property and finds it unsatisfactory, is the earnest money returned? Or if the agreement is terminated by mutual consent, who receives the money?
What happens if the contract is breached? Of course, the smaller the amount of earnest money you pay, the less this really matters. But a word of caution here:
Many gurus recommend that you pay only $5 or $10 in earnest money and write in a provision that allows you to terminate your contract with the seller and you’ll only lose your earnest money and nothing else.
I don’t disagree with the fundamental idea behind this, but be aware of this: There probably isn’t a judge anywhere in the USA who will allow you to get out of a real estate transaction with damages of only $5 if your decision to terminate the transaction doesn’t have a legitimate basis. So don’t plan to use a real estate contract with a tiny earnest money deposit as a proxy purchase option, because that strategy just won’t pass muster if it goes to court.
I’d love to hear about your experiences and strategies with earnest money! Tell us all about it in the comments area below, and thanks for visiting FreeRealEstateTraining.com!